Reactivity on three axes

The outline. No tables were harmed.

  1. Depth: what's the smallest change noticed?
    • Shallow: reassign to update (React, Lit, signals)
    • Deep: proxies catch nested writes (Vue, MobX, Solid stores)
  2. Granularity: how narrow is the update?
    • Coarse: window or subtree (Zone.js, React)
    • Fine: one DOM node (signals, Solid, Svelte 5)
  3. Direction: pushed to dependents or pulled at render?
    • Pull: re-render top down (React, Lit, Angular)
    • Push-pull: signals, with scheduling to avoid glitches
    • Push: Svelte 4, about as close as anyone gets
  4. Takeaways
    • Detection and response are separate concerns
    • Every system has an escape hatch
    • Fine-grained frameworks converge: read to subscribe, write to notify
    • The diamond problem decides push vs. pull